Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Record ID: 34ca4430-d997-41f4-9aa9-f052a3cb7b69
Type: Journal Article
Title: Beyond the victim-offender binary: Legal and anti-violence intervention considerations with women who have used force in the U.S. and Australia
Authors: Douglas, Heather
Larance, Lisa Young
Kertesz, Margaret
Humphreys, Cathy
Goodmark, Leigh
ANRA Topic: Other
Policing and legal responses
ANRA Population: General population
Year: 2021
Publisher: Sage journals
Abstract:  In the United States (U.S.) and Australian contexts, the fight to achieve legal and societal recognition of cisgender men's violence against cisgender women operated according to an incident-based victim-offender binary. Those held accountable for the violence were seen as offenders, those who survived the violence were seen as victims. This binary persists across police, court, corrections, intervention, and child protection settings. However, work with cisgender heterosexual women with offenses of abuse and violence demonstrates that the binary does not capture their complex experiences. Instead, they have “offended” in the context of often surviving long-term harm in their families of origin and from their intimate partners. Because their experiences do not align with the binary, they are caught in ineffective and retraumatizing responses. The authors use an intersectional theoretical framework to explore how heterosexual cisgender women's use of force complicates the victim-offender binary. By understanding women who have used force as having both survived and caused harm, rather than “victims” or “offenders,” the authors call attention to the limitations of, and harm caused by, binary approaches. The authors also call for a reconceptualization beyond the binary—challenging established legal and intervention frameworks. To demonstrate the need for this reconceptualization, the authors report on U.S. and Australian legal cases, intervention approaches, and discuss socio-legal systems implications.
Appears in Collections:ANROWS Notepad 2021
Journal Articles

Files in This Item:
There are no files associated with this item.

Items in ANROWS library are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

Google Media

Google ScholarTM

Who's citing